Splitting up a large workflow using External Signal | Community
Skip to main content
A
alistairk161838
Level 3
March 16, 2017
Solved

Splitting up a large workflow using External Signal

  • March 16, 2017
  • 22 replies
  • 11647 views

Hi,

I have a large complicated workflow which runs at the end of each campaign which summarises findings and then emails this to stakeholders.

Ideally I want to split this into two parts, the simply delivery part and the complicated summarisation part. The simple part will allow the operators to select their data and delivery templates and send the email. The complicated part does a ton of analysis work and delivers some files. The operators should never touch any of the complicated part.

I was thinking to put a signal at the end of the simple part which after X amount of time will trigger the complicated part, passing through the required variables to enable it to determine the campaign it needs to analyse and deliver the automated reports for.

How best to do this? I looked at signals and I think this is the best way, however I'm unsure of exactly how to trigger a signal from a workflow. 

 

Appreciate your input!

    This post is no longer active and is closed to new replies. Need help? Start a new post to ask your question.
    Best answer by vraghav

    Hi Alistair,

    Signal seems to best suit your requirement. 

    Each signal activity has an internal name and this is something which helps trigger the signal.

    So at the end of simple part you can put a JS code activity.

    Use the following code

    xtk.workflow.PostEvent('Identifier or internal name of the workflow which contains signal activity', 'The name of the activity from which the event starts', 'The name of the transition to activate. If this name is empty, the event will be issued on the first valid transition', 'The parameters of the event in the form of an XML element. The name of the element must be variables.', 0)

    Hope this helps.

    Regards,

    Vipul

    22 replies

    Show previous replies
    vraghav
    Adobe Employee
    vraghavAdobe Employee
    Adobe Employee
    March 17, 2017

    It is unable to understand attribute workflow-id in delivery schema. Please check the name of foreign key link to xtk:workflow and use that here. It will work then

    vraghav
    Adobe Employee
    vraghavAdobe Employee
    Adobe Employee
    March 17, 2017

    Hi Alistair,

    Made a small mistake, forgot the @ symbol

    Use this as expression for where clause

    expr={"[@workflow-id]=" + instance.id}

    Split is a JS fundtion which will take string like this as input1 "deliveryid1,deliveryid2,deliveryid3" and a delimiter as input 2 i.e. ','

    It will output an array [deliveryid1, deliveryid2, deliveryid3]

    You can then loop through this array to perform your logic.

    This link should help http://stackoverflow.com/questions/3245088/how-to-split-a-comma-separated-string-and-process-in-a-loop-using-javascript

    Regards,

    Vipul

    A
    alistairk161838Author
    Level 3
    March 17, 2017

    Hi Vipul,

    Thanks for your patience here. That code is working (apart from one thing I will mention at the end);

    // Define Delivery Variable var query = xtk.queryDef.create( <queryDef schema="nms:delivery" operation="select"> <select> <node expr="@id"/> </select> <where> <condition expr={"[@workflow-id]=" + instance.id}/> </where> </queryDef>); var resultSet = query.ExecuteQuery(); for each (var row in resultSet) { vars.myVar = row.@id; logInfo(vars.myVar); } //Pass through Variable xtk.workflow.PostEvent('WKF129','signal','', <variables varName= {vars.myVar} />,false)

    It logs the following two Delivery IDs. These are correct.

     

    In my signal workflow I have the JS script;

    //  Split Variable var myArray = vars.varName.split(','); //  Define in vars vars.delId1 = myArray[0]; vars.delId2 = myArray[1]; vars.delId2 = myArray[2]; //  logInfo(vars.varName); logInfo(vars.delId1); logInfo(vars.delId2); logInfo(vars.delId3);

    This logs the following delivery ID variables;

    As you can see it takes only a single value instead of the two listed in the previous logs.

    At what point are the delivery IDs parsed into a comma separated string? If I log the vars.varName variable it only has a single Delivery ID in it - the value I'm placing into vars.del1.

     

    Final thing to mention, as you may remember my test workflow consisted of an AB test and a winning delivery, so I would expect to see three Delivery IDs, instead there only seem to be two present. The winning Delivery is not being picked up with that script. I suspect this is due to the way it is being generated and that perhaps it is not correctly assigning itself to this workflow. The script used for this winning Delivery is taken from the Adobe Campaign Use Case documentation. Would it be possible to take a look and see if this is the case?

    vraghav
    Adobe Employee
    vraghavAdobe Employee
    Adobe Employee
    March 19, 2017

    Hi Alistair,

    There are few missing points and hence you are facing this issue.

    1. The Campaign documentation explaining the script for selecting winner delivery just duplicates one of the A or B delivery and assigns the operation-id to it. In other words, the winner delivery is only being linked with the campaign.You'll have to add another line to this code so that attribute [@workflow-id] is populated with instance.id and then it will get picked by your queryDef.
    2. In you script towards the build up to PostEvent, when you are looping through the deliveryIds, it is required to develop a comma separated string of deliveryIds there itself. At present, it is not being done and hence only the last delivery is being passed to signal. Following code
      var resultSet = query.ExecuteQuery(); for each (var row in resultSet) { vars.myVar = row.@id; logInfo(vars.myVar); }
        should be changed to 
      var resultSet = query.ExecuteQuery(); var commaSeparatedDeliveryIds; for each (var row in resultSet) { commaSeparatedDeliveryIds = commaSeparatedDeliveryIds + row.@id + ","; //Generate comma separated list of deliveryIds logInfo(commaSeparatedDeliveryIds); } vars.myVar = commaSeparatedDeliveryIds.replace(/,\s*$/, ""); //Replace last comma and trailing whitespaces with blankspace

       

    alistairk396804
    alistairk396804
    Level 3
    March 20, 2017

    Hi Vipul,

    Thanks for your pointers on amending the bits of code. As I'm sure you are not surprised by I have a couple of questions;

    Amending the 'Winner' JS script. I think I may have got this backwards?

    // link the delivery to the operation to make sure it will be displayed in // the campaign dashboard. This attribute needs to be set manually here since // the Duplicate() method has reset it to its default value => 0 delivery.operation_id = winner.@["operation-id"] delivery.workflow_id = winner.@["instance-id"]

    Concatenating the delivery ids.The updated code you supplied displays this (I'm displaying the final output with the end comma removed) so this appears to be working (I assume the lack of the delivery ID from the winning delivery is causing the undefined/lack of comma result).

    Ignore my previous split questions - user error. I was overwriting [1] with [2].

    I really do appreciate your help on this!

    alistairk396804
    alistairk396804
    Level 3
    March 20, 2017

    Hi Vipul,

    The first part of the problem is the circular logic in this piece of code.

    { commaSeparatedDeliveryIds = commaSeparatedDeliveryIds + row.@id + ","; //Generate comma separated list of deliveryIds }

    The commaSeperatedDeliveryIds variable is being used to define itself when it doesn't actually contain any info yet, therefore always returns 'undefined'. It also doesn't comma between itself and row.id. For example it returns 'undefined4242971,4241831'. If you move the commaSeperatedDeliveryIds variable about in the code then the 'undefined' value moves around too.
     

    vraghav
    Adobe Employee
    vraghavAdobe Employee
    Adobe Employee
    March 23, 2017

    alistairk39680404 wrote...

    Hi Vipul,

    The first part of the problem is the circular logic in this piece of code.

    1. {
    2. commaSeparatedDeliveryIds = commaSeparatedDeliveryIds + row.@id + ","; //Generate comma separated list of deliveryIds
    3. }

    The commaSeperatedDeliveryIds variable is being used to define itself when it doesn't actually contain any info yet, therefore always returns 'undefined'. It also doesn't comma between itself and row.id. For example it returns 'undefined4242971,4241831'. If you move the commaSeperatedDeliveryIds variable about in the code then the 'undefined' value moves around too.
     

     

    Hi Alistair,

    The variable commaSeparatedDeliveryIds is initially undefined and hence the keyword is getting appended with your deliveryIds.

    When defining the variable we can initialize it 

    var commaSeparatedDeliveryIds = "";

    This will fix the problem.

    For the workflow id problem, as stated above you can use instance.id directly. I believe you have already figured it out on the related thread.

    Please let me know if you have any queries.

    Regards,

    Vipul

    A
    alistairk161838Author
    Level 3
    March 23, 2017

    Hi Vipul,

    That's all fine thanks. I actually used my brain and solved it :). I did have another question on how best to interrogate the received split array but I've put together an inelegant solution which does the trick.

    Appreciate all your help.

    richam007
    richam007
    July 3, 2017

    Hi,

    Can you please help me with the following scenario:

    I need to create an Engagement Split for an email. Engagers of Email 1 get mobile alert while non-engagers of Email 1 get Email 2.

    Cab you please guide me how to implement this scenario in workflow?

    Thanks,

    Richa

    Adhiyan
    Adobe Employee
    AdhiyanAdobe Employee
    Adobe Employee
    July 3, 2017

    Hello Richa,

    The split will be based on what you consider to be responders (open/clicks) for email1

    Taking email clicks as responders for example , you can create a workflow like this

    1>. External signal from previous workflow

    2>. Query activity targeting the recipients of the delivery EMAIL1

    3>. Split activity connected to the query with Generate complement option selected from the general tab . On the Subsets tab click on "add a filtering condition to the inbound population , click on Edit and select the filtering dimension as a temporary schema and select the query result as source.

    Then add a filtering condition like shown in the screenshot here : TrackingLogRcp exists such as url/@type=email-click.

    4>. Add the subset to the SMS delivery and add the complement to the Email2 to send SMS to responders and email2 to non-responders.

    Hope this helps.

    Regards,

    Adhiyan

      Show more replies
      Terms & ConditionsAccessibility statement

      Loading footer...