Skip to main content
Andrew_Wathen_
Community Advisor
Community Advisor
Nov 15, 2017 2:37 PM UTC
New

Segment Builder: Improve Before/After sequence options

Currently there are the following 2 options within the segment builder:

  • Only Before Sequence
  • Only After Sequence (which actually seems include the sequence itself as well)

Although these are a welcome improvement they don't allow enough flexibility to really be able to drive the maximum value out of the solution (which means we don't use it as much as we should).

I would like to see the 2 options replaced with the following 5 option:

  • Before the sequence (excluding the sequence itself)
  • Before the sequence (including the sequence itself)
  • The sequence (everything between the start and end of the sequence)
  • After the sequence (excluding the sequence itself)
  • After the sequence (including the sequence itself)

I think these would be a logic and useful extension of the existing functionality which would significantly increase the value of the capability - please can this be considered?

10 replies

trevor-paulsen
Adobe Employee
Adobe Employee
Nov 15, 2017 3:00 PM UTC

Fantastic idea! I'll see if I can get this added to the backlog.

Translate
EricMatisoff
Adobe Employee
Adobe Employee
Nov 15, 2017 3:01 PM UTC

I agree with all of these. The biggest one that I've needed for analysis is the third one:

  • The sequence (everything between the start and end of the sequence)

Great idea Andrew!

Translate
Urs_Boller
Community Advisor
Community Advisor
Nov 15, 2017 7:20 PM UTC

the sequence between was on my wish list, i‘m happy you had the time to write it here! thanks a lot for the great input!

Translate
Gigazelle
Adobe Employee
Adobe Employee
Nov 15, 2017 8:27 PM UTC

Perhaps instead of having 5 options, you could have 3 checkboxes that you could include/exclude any combination of the following:

  • Before the sequence
  • During the sequence
  • After the sequence

So if you wanted to include everything during the sequence and everything after, you could check 'during' and 'after'.

Translate
trevor-paulsen
Adobe Employee
Adobe Employee
Feb 7, 2018 4:22 PM UTC

So, looking at this, it's a little more complex than it sounds like - for example, let's say I have a sequence of hits:

a -> b -> a -> c -> a -> d -> b

and I create a sequential sequence "a then b",

How would you want "before the sequence", "during the sequence", and "after the sequence" to work?

Translate
Level 4
Mar 30, 2018 10:19 PM UTC

Could the above scenario be addressed with the addition of 2 more options

Wide or Narrow - "Narrow" picks the first A and first B, while "wide" picks first A and last B
First, Last or All - This option is only available if "narrow" is selected, and defines which instance of the sequence I'm interested in viewing

Translate
jantzen_b
Adobe Employee
Adobe Employee
Oct 27, 2020 10:59 PM UTC
No text available
Translate
Community Manager
Oct 5, 2022 7:04 PM UTC
No text available
Translate
RobertBlakeley
Community Advisor
Community Advisor
Nov 9, 2023 1:42 PM UTC

@ericmatisoff 

This is from 2017 but came up again recently in the Questions. Is this suggestion off the table?

Translate
EricMatisoff
Adobe Employee
Adobe Employee
Nov 16, 2023 9:37 PM UTC

I've passed this one along over to our product management team as a reminder, thanks @robertblakeley 

Translate