Skip to main content
Dan_Stevens_
Level 10
Feb 15, 2018 1:15 PM UTC
Question

[Shared Blog]: I Want to Believe, But: Your Email Link Clicks Aren’t Real

I recently came across this external blog post by @Courtney Grimes​ and thought it would be useful to share with the community (great post, btw, Courtney).  Especially since there has been a lot of discussion/questions recently on false-positives of email opens and clicks:

demandlab.com/insights/blog/want-believe-email-link-clicks-arent-real/

I did want to comment on the guidance to combat this:

After testing this idea on dozens of different Marketo instances, the single most effective way I’ve found to track email clicks is a combination of two filters: Email was delivered + Visited web page: [web page linked to in email]

Typically, one would simply add these two filters to the smart list of the trigger campaign.  When we tried that in the past, it didn't work for us since Marketo doesn't log this activity immediately as it happens - at least not in our case (especially the "visited web page" activity).  We've seen up to a 45 minute delay.  So we used an alternate approach: we included a "visited web page" choice in our "change program status" flow step.  And prior to that flow step, we also included a 45 minute wait step.  The only issue with this approach is if the user ever visited this page in the past, the choice will still be true.  In other words, the choice step is not directly tied to this instance of the email click.

As Courtney states in her wrap-up, there really is no fool-proof solution.  But if you had to pick one, this is probably the best approach.

This post is no longer active and is closed to new replies. Need help? Start a new post to ask your question.

46 replies

Grégoire_Miche2
Level 10
Mar 21, 2018 10:50 PM UTC

Vote here:

Translate
Michael_Guanci
Level 2
Apr 13, 2018 2:17 PM UTC

So far we have had decent results using a combination of Dan's method and Sanford's redirect.  However, I noticed that some members from eBay are getting counted as a real click even though they all happen within a minute after the email is sent/delivered.  They are clicking the link and visiting the page that has the re-direct.

This is for our ABM program so we want to include eBay in this moving forward (we don't want to exclude them is what I am saying), is there a time constraint I can add that I am not thinking of?  Like did not click on email within 3 minutes of being sent?  I am following the guidelines Dan outlined for the 30 minute wait and seeing if they visit the web page. 

Translate
Marketo_HyperX_
Level 1
Oct 10, 2018 9:29 PM UTC

Our Customer Support Manager Mariska noticed that the clicks happen 1 minute before the email is delivered.  Did you all see the same behavior?

To avoid wait steps, do you think this would work:

Thanks!

Amy

Translate
SanfordWhiteman
User Group Leader
User Group Leader
Oct 10, 2018 9:42 PM UTC

Your Smart Campaign doesn't reflect the order your describe. Please look at it more closely. Also: give up on trying to solve this using Smart Campaigns.

Translate
Marketo_HyperX_
Level 1
Oct 10, 2018 9:53 PM UTC

Hi Sanford.  The false click happens 1 minute before the email is actually delivered.  Thus, I believe my smart campaign logic is correct and will filter out the false clicks.  Thoughts?  

Translate