It's the "Connect with us" tab - Facebook page.
I understand your points, but since I built this using the Publish to Facebook, I can't figure out why it won't work.
I have undone the workaround and now the Thank you is chosen in the manner it which it should be.
Thank you.
Doesn't really matter how you built it, everything it does has to obey browser security rules.
You've embedded the https: page directly from your Marketo LP domain (not its CNAME): https://na-ab14.marketo.com/lp/343-GYD-722/LP-ICI-FB.html?fbTab=1&liked=true. That's secure.
Your Thank You URL page uses your CNAME lp.icihomes.com, and you haven't given Marketo an SSL cert to protect that domain. That's not secure.
Thus the clear error in the browser console:
Workaround is to use https://na-ab14 for the TY URL as well.
I'm actually pretty sure I've answered this exact question before, now that I think about it... should come up in a Community search.