Submit data to Authoring instance | Community
Skip to main content
N
nbg62
Level 4
February 10, 2022
Solved

Submit data to Authoring instance

  • February 10, 2022
  • 3 replies
  • 2118 views

We have requirement to submit custom form (client is not using Forms) that resides on the public website but we're not allowed to store submitted data inside publishing JCR  but only directly to authoring instance, it's AEM on the cloud solution.

Is there any solution that will allow us to implement this ?

 

Thanks

This post is no longer active and is closed to new replies. Need help? Start a new post to ask your question.
Best answer by joerghoh

When user (anonymous) submits data, we're capturing that data in sling model on publishing, from there we could call and pass data to sling servlet running on authoring, when we have data on authoring we could store it to jcr, this should do the trick ?

 

This is problematic for a number of reasons:

* you need to store credentials on publish which they can use for authentication against the authoring instance. Brittle ...

* What do you do if a request from publish to author fails (for whatever reason)? As you are in a synchronous request/response model, any retry delays the response to your enduser. 

 

My feeling is that you are re-building functionality, which is already available in AEM Forms. Squeezing everything into the author/publish model you have right now is probably possible, but comes for the prize of additional work on your side (design/development/test + maintenance).

 

 

3 replies

S
sdouglasmcSonova
Level 4
February 10, 2022

You might want to consider using an External Data Store for this.  Possibly use a microservice to handle the transaction. 

    N
    nbg62Author
    Level 4
    February 10, 2022

    Client requirement is to use JCR, they discarded option with external storage.

      S
      sdouglasmcSonova
      Level 4
      February 10, 2022

      ughhh

        Nitin_laad
        Community Advisor
        Nitin_laadCommunity Advisor
        Community Advisor
        February 10, 2022

        Hey @nbg62 , just a food for thought.. content fragment can be used  to store structured data and using AssetHttp API you can perform CRUD operation on stored CFs. 

        So solution should like convert form data in CF and invoke microservice using AssetHTTP API on author server. 

         

         

          N
          nbg62Author
          Level 4
          February 11, 2022

          Thanks, will review this option as well.

            joerghoh
            Adobe Employee
            joerghohAdobe Employee
            Adobe Employee
            February 12, 2022

            I don't think that there is a way to implement this without an external system. Assuming that the endusers (which submit that data) do not have credentials to access the author environment.

             

            In that case they would need to submit their data to an external system which itself then connects to AEM author to store the data. Actually I would recommend you to use an external storage (as already suggested) or use AEM Forms. Because the effort to build and maintain such a solution is non-trivial.

             

              N
              nbg62Author
              Level 4
              February 13, 2022

              Thanks Jörg,

               

              When user (anonymous) submits data, we're capturing that data in sling model on publishing, from there we could call and pass data to sling servlet running on authoring, when we have data on authoring we could store it to jcr, this should do the trick ?

               

              Regarding authentication from publishing to authoring, I guess we could generate a long-lived secret JWT from cloud console and use it to authenticate from publishing sling model to authoring servlet  

               

              Is this approach worth considering ?

               

                joerghoh
                Adobe Employee
                joerghohAdobe EmployeeAccepted solution
                Adobe Employee
                February 13, 2022

                When user (anonymous) submits data, we're capturing that data in sling model on publishing, from there we could call and pass data to sling servlet running on authoring, when we have data on authoring we could store it to jcr, this should do the trick ?

                 

                This is problematic for a number of reasons:

                * you need to store credentials on publish which they can use for authentication against the authoring instance. Brittle ...

                * What do you do if a request from publish to author fails (for whatever reason)? As you are in a synchronous request/response model, any retry delays the response to your enduser. 

                 

                My feeling is that you are re-building functionality, which is already available in AEM Forms. Squeezing everything into the author/publish model you have right now is probably possible, but comes for the prize of additional work on your side (design/development/test + maintenance).

                 

                 

                  Terms & ConditionsAccessibility statement

                  Loading footer...